SFO ATC Frustrated by Inefficient Qatar Airways Pilot Communication. As an ardent aviation enthusiast, my fascination with air traffic control audio recordings consistently draws me to the VASAviation YouTube channel. Known for its captivating coverage of intriguing air traffic control interactions, VASAviation recently unveiled an episode that spotlights a captivating exchange between a Qatar Airways pilot and air traffic control.
Read Also: Qatar Airways Announces Fourth Daily Doha-Dubai Flight
SFO ATC Frustrated by Inefficient Qatar Airways Pilot Communication
VASAviation has released a compelling audio-visual representation of a recent communication exchange involving an Airbus A350-1000 from Qatar Airways en route from San Francisco (SFO) to Doha (DOH).
In the realm of aviation, precision is paramount, especially in terms of pilots accurately relaying and adhering to instructions from air traffic controllers. This importance amplifies on the ground, where the stakes are higher and missteps can yield dangerous outcomes. There’s no room for error in these circumstances.
While air traffic controllers are known to speak rapidly, inundating pilots with directives, this is an anticipated challenge that pilots are well-prepared to handle. Their pre-flight preparations include a thorough study of airport charts and familiarization with an airport’s operational procedures.
In this particular case, a Qatar Airways aircraft was taxiing to runway 28R at SFO for takeoff, but communication took a messy turn, to say the least. What elevates the situation’s gravity is not a single blunder but the accumulation of consecutive mistakes:
- The Qatar Airways pilots were supposed to be on the San Francisco tower frequency (critical when crossing active runways), but they were not, leading to a delayed correction.
- The controller expressed frustration after multiple failed attempts to reach the pilot: “Third time we’re trying to call you; you must be on the frequency if we’re going to move you.”
- The pilot misread taxi instructions for reaching the departure runway, overlooking the crossing of runway 1L and failing to hold short of runway 28L.
- The controller’s irritation grew as the pilot committed multiple readback errors: “That’s like three readback errors in a row; you need to listen more carefully.”
- The pilot, inexplicably, indicated that they would contact NorCal departures, a task performed post-takeoff. This prompted the controller to intervene: “No, why would you contact NorCal? I’m still working you. I have multiple airplanes on frequency. Listen for the callsign!”
Collectively, these mistakes are cause for concern. Notably, the pilot’s decision to contact NorCal departures before receiving takeoff clearance is a misstep even a novice private pilot would typically avoid. This lapse in judgment appears to stem from a lack of situational awareness.
Divergent Perspectives on the Exchange
Reactions to this interaction span a wide spectrum, reflecting varying viewpoints within the aviation community. Notable observations include:
- Fatigue and Language Proficiency: Qatar Airways pilots, along with their counterparts at other Gulf carriers, often grapple with profound fatigue, particularly on extensive routes such as San Francisco. However, exhaustion is not seen as a valid excuse for factual inaccuracies. Notably, language proficiency, while a potential factor, does not absolve the pilot of inaccuracies.
- Pilots’ Eyewitness Accounts: Eyewitness accounts from pilots in nearby aircraft provide intriguing insights. Some found humor in the situation, expressing bewilderment at the pilot’s communications challenges. Others questioned whether it was the crew’s first time in SFO.
- Understanding Junior Pilot Challenges: Some commenters demonstrated empathy for the Qatar Airways pilot, suggesting that the air traffic controller should have exercised restraint, given the challenging conditions. They posited that a junior first officer, seated in the right seat, might face heightened stress, especially when grappling with fast-paced communication in a foreign language and misunderstandings about runway references.
An unanswered question lingers: Why didn’t the captain briefly assume control of communications during this challenging exchange, especially given the four-pilot setup typical on long-haul flights?
Read Also: Qatar Airways Appoints New CEO to Succeed Industry Icon
Conclusion
The spotlight now shines on a remarkable exchange between SFO ATC and a Qatar Airways A350 pilot. The pilot’s multiple errors, though not unprecedented, culminated in the unusual assertion that they should contact NorCal departures without having received takeoff clearance.
This occurrence highlights the importance of clear and precise communication within the aviation industry and serves as a reminder that even experienced pilots can experience moments of miscommunication.